George Monbiot is doubling down on the lies he and Tony Jones made in the debate they had with Ian Plimer. Monbiot has a new article out reinforcing these lies indirectly. The article has the heading:
“Should climate deniers be allowed to speak on the Today programme?
Had the BBC done its research, Ian Plimer’s falsehoods would not been allowed to pass unchallenged”
WHAT FALSEHOODS WOULD THAT BE GEORGE YOU LIAR? George Monbiot isn’t about to answer that question. The falsehoods came from Monbiot and Jones. And Monbiot continues to reinforce these falsehoods almost daily by not admitting he has no clue as to the CO2 output of volcanoes.
Monbiot made an idiot of himself in that debate. It was Monbiot who refused to answer any questions on climate science. Whereas Plimer wrote a book on the matter and answered the questions in the book. He also answered the questions during the debate when he could get a word in edge-ways.
Plimer, during this rigup, made it quite clear where his estimate for volcanic CO2 was coming from. From the chemistry of sedimentary rocks. This was his proxy.
The Monbiot/Jones claims were total idiocy. It was outrageous. Since Monbiot and Jones, and this ought to be a sackable offense for Jones, chose to make gospel a 1991 study that claimed that sub-sea volcanic emissions and open air volcanic emissions were roughly similar. A self-evidently ridiculous contention in 2009.
It was George Monbiot who would answer no questions. Monbiot merely deflected the fact that it was he who would answer no questions, by claiming it was Plimer who would not answer any questions.
All Monbiot did was refuse to answer questions and claim frantically that it was Plimer who was doing this. In other words this was a frantic leftist reversal from Monbiot.
Plimer gave us enough facts for anyone with a brain to see that the claims of Monbiot and Tony Jones were utter idiocy. Plimer managed to mention, through constant interruptions from the liar and fraud George Monbiot, that there are an estimated 240,000 underwater volcanoes, and 68,000 kilometres of volcanic underwater rift zones.
So if industrial activity was to release 130 times as much CO2 as volcanoes. If this were the case as Monbiot and Jones, being complete idiots and liars, had claimed, this would be more than the CO2 output of a hypothetical 31,200,000 underwater volcanoes added to the equivalent of 8,840,000 kilometres of underwater riftzones. How on earth do the idiots Monbiot and Jones think this nonsense could even be possible? That many riftzones ringing endlessly around the globe in such a way as we could never get away from volcanic activity. Monbiot and Jones contend that this many volcanoes and this extent of riftzones would only let out approximately the same amount of CO2 as human industry. Morons like this ought not be employable beyond the cleaning of toilets or some such other menial job. We are in a culture now that makes idiots like Jones and Monbiot upwardly mobile. And this is cultural suicide. Such people should be pushed aside so that individuals who can do the job get the opportunity to excel. The success of our civilisation depends on this realisation.
So it was Monbiot, Tony Jones and anyone who fell for their charade, who were shown to be idiots during and after this alleged debate, and not Plimer. Anyone with any affinity for science would have understood this. Anyone who didn’t understand this has shown themselves up to be a failed analyst and ought not be teaching the children, as they often are.
Jones ought to be sacked over this attempt to mislead the public. I want someone to even come up with one fraudulent claim that they reckon Plimer has made. This is a lie. Plimer has made no such fraudulent claims. The fraud was carried over on the public by Tony Jones and George Monbiot. If this is not the case let the two of these miscreants come up with a credible estimate for volcanic CO2 release.